What Would You Do?

Posted Wednesday, June 10, 2009
by Jason Bell

What would you do?A consumer hires Anonymous Remodelers to draw up the plans for a home renovation project. That same consumer then hires Afterthought Handymen to implement the plans. When the project is completed, doors won’t open properly, pipes are leaking, and the guest bedroom smells like something died in it. Afterthought Handymen claims they are not at fault and that the plans provided by Anonymous Remodelers must have contained errors. Anonymous claims that the plans were perfect and that Afterthought must have done a poor job following them. Since neither business is willing to fix the problems with this project, the consumer decides to call the BBB and file a complaint about Anonymous Remodelers (the company that provided the plans). What would you do in Anonymous Remodelers’ shoes?

Comments

eoR61M IJWTS wow! Why can't I think of things like that?
Comment By Vyolet At 4/8/2011 5:35 PM
hR4gXp I'm not easily impressed. . . but that's impressing me! :)
Comment By Johnavon At 4/8/2011 5:10 PM
Yes, The home owner should not be picking on the designer. The problem is between after thought handyman and the homeowner. Cheaper is not always better. Better is better. You get what you pay for. We fix heating mistakes made by others - who may have charged less. Our advice: Never take the lowest bidder. Good luck! Steve Aquacaresolar.com (solar heating)
Comment By Steve Ruby At 4/19/2010 6:47 PM
If a consumer hires a registered Architect to perform 'full services',
the consumer will receive detailed plans and specifications and Construction Phase oversight that will go a long way toward protecting the homeowner and assuring that the project is built to code and follows the original Construction Documents (plans). An architect's review of the project as it moves along should ascertain if there are oversights or problems with the work. The architect's role is not only to design the look of the project and translate the client's wishes into instructions for it's execution; but also, to protect the interests of the owner and project as a whole!
Comment By Jeff Abrams At 6/30/2009 4:26 PM
Consumers want to save money. That's more than understandable. However, they most often do not do their due diligence. They hire service people based on the lowest bid which is not always the best choice. Part of doing due diligence is using the BBB and other resources to obtain information about the company you wish to hire.

In this case, Anonymous Remodelers is not at fault. I believe that they assumed that they would be getting the work. The consumer's complaint lies with Afterthought Handymen because they did the work. If there was a fault in the plans and if they knew what they were doing, they could have made the necessary changes as they were doing the work. If Anonymous Remodelers is a business with integrity, they should at least go over the work that was done and document the cause of the problems for the consumer so that she can seek relief in court. Although my company, Grandma's Handyman Service, Inc., specializes in home repair and maintenance and we do not do major remodeling, that is what we would do. And, if we were Anonymous Remodelers, we would add a disclaimer to our plans that says, 'We are only responsible for work completed by Anonymous Remodelers and are not responsible for work completed by others using our plans.'

The consumer can also hire a home inspector to document the problems with the home as a result of the work that was done. This would give her additional ammunition in court.
Comment By Yvonne Costin, Grandma's Handyman Service, Inc. At 6/16/2009 10:25 AM

Add a Comment

We would love for you to comment on posts to the Blog.

But please, let’s keep it clean. Comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments will be removed. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. Finally, we will take steps to block users who violate the guidelines, terms of use or privacy policy governing this site. We advise review of our Blog Frequently Asked Questions, Submission Rules and Terms of Use prior to comment submission.

Name
Email
Comments

5000 characters remaining
Enter the code shown:

Tools

  • Print
  • RSS
  • Bookmark & Share
    • MySpace
    • Digg
    • Delicious
    • StumbleUpon
Sign up for our monthly consumer newsletter!